Bellagio Pizzeria in New York

"I had a catering event with trays of eggplant parm, chicken marsala, penne ala vodka and sausage and meatballs. They included a tray of garlic bread with my order. Everything was delicious and there was very few left overs. Renee was very attentive while taking my order over the phone. She repeated the order so she can accurately place the order. Joel and Renee are always so friendly. When I am looking for great italian food, I alway go to Bellagio Pizza."

"Great pizza, great garlic knots. Good prices. Much recommended you go here."

"Kinda disappointed... Why does a good slice of pizza (plain slice) cost almost $4.00. (and that's cash price add 4% if you use a cc!!!) That's a rip imo. ( NYC maybe, LI ng) Although you will not be disappointed here since everything in the display case looked absolutely delicious! Rarely could I say that of other pizza places. A big plus for Bellagio! Even though I only had a plain slice it was cooked well, with a nice balance of sauce & cheese, spices, and a crispy crust, I enjoyed very much! Service was quick and easy. Unfortunately I probably won't be back but sure wish I could try one or two of those other slices, pin wheels, or rolls, etc. they did look good! The place gives off a cold " industrial" feeling, concrete floors, metal chairs/tables. (One less star for atmosphere) Lmk what you think."

"Couldn’t find a sign anywhere saying Halal but I did ask someone and they said yes. Got a chicken Parm hero. They kind of burnt it a little bit, but it was still good. I wish there was a bit more kickoff flavor but then again it is a classic chicken Parm. Chicken sauce, cheese, bread . The pizza was also good too get a plain slice. There is some seating inside as well as parking. Nice and clean inside."

"Bellagio is the place to stop and get a slice or a plate I promise u. Best pizza in Farmingdale. Their staff is amazing food is amaze-balls. The short curly hair girl make u feel so great after interacting with her. She puts a smile on my face every time. Stop by Bellagios Pizza don’t miss out"

"Because I come from an Italian restaurant background, it’s hard for me to find authentic Italian recipes being made. The Chicken Francese was amazing! You could tell the quality of the Chicken was top notch. Also, the Lemon Butter sauce was just that…. No Garlic. That’s because its not supposed to have garlic. It’s a Lemon Butter Sauce. I had their Buffalo Chicken Roll while I waited for my take out. It is Huge! Had 2 meals from it. It was so delicious. The young team behind the counter was paying attention and greeted me immediately. Asked me more then once of if I needed anything else. The young man actually raved about the Chicken Roll and that’s why I tried it. I can’t wait to go back. Maybe tonight! Thanks for the excellent food and service. Oh yeah, it was also very clean. Bellow is picture of Chichen Roll before it’s cut and heated. Then Half of it after cut and heated."

"Bellagio Pizzeria is a husband-and-wife-owned treasure that brings warmth, authenticity, and bold flavor to every dish they serve. What sets this spot apart isn't just the amazing food—it’s the fact that every item is halal, a rare find when it comes to such classic Italian-American comfort dishes. We ordered a pizza pie split between buffalo chicken and pepperoni—each half was packed with flavor and perfectly baked. The crust had the right crunch, and the toppings were generous and fresh. The Penne alla Vodka with crispy chicken was creamy, rich, and comforting, while the Rigatoni Florentine with charred grilled chicken delivered a beautiful balance of smokiness and savory sauce. Every bite felt carefully crafted. But the star for us might’ve been the Meatball Parm on garlic bread. Hearty, flavorful meatballs smothered in sauce and cheese, nestled in garlicky, toasty bread—it was indulgent in the best way. Bellagio Pizzeria isn’t just serving halal food—it’s delivering top-tier flavor that rivals (or beats) the usual favorites, with the added comfort of knowing everything is halal. A must-try spot whether you're local or just passing through"

"Being Muslim, not all places cater to Islamic (halal) dietary restrictions. Bellagio Pizzaria does!!! I connected with the owner Joel a day before visiting. He gave recommendations on which are the popular items and which could be modified to meet my needs. I chose the Rigatoni Florentine and absolutely loved it!!! (Even got another to go for my family!!) My friend got a plain slice and a chicken roll (that too is halal!) The staff all knew what options were halal. They were all super friendly and welcoming. The place is really cute and folks were just coming in - which can tell you how good the food is! Will be returning again for sure!! Thank you Joel for being so amazing and kind! And giving the Muslim community a great Italian place to eat!!!"